英國樞密院支持傑森・瓊斯的上訴,裁定千里達及托巴哥成人合意同性性行為禁令違憲
UK Privy Council backs Jason Jones’s challenge to Trinidad and Tobago’s ban on consensual same-sex activity
Updated at: November 12, 2026 at 01:14 AM
英國樞密院司法委員會11月10日就千里達及托巴哥一宗案件裁定傑森・瓊斯勝訴。他質疑把成年同性之間私下合意的性行為列為犯罪的法律。
The UK's Judicial Committee of the Privy Council ruled for Jason Jones on November 10 in a case from Trinidad and Tobago. He challenged laws that criminalised private, consensual sexual activity between adults of the same sex.
瓊斯主張,該國1986年《性犯罪法》的兩個條文侵犯憲法保障的權利,尤其是私人及家庭生活應受尊重的權利。
Jones argued that two sections of the country's 1986 Sexual Offences Act violated rights guaranteed by its constitution. His case focused in particular on the right to respect for private and family life.
該國高等法院原先認同他的主張。後來上訴法院恢復了條文的大部分效力,理由是憲法可以保護1976年憲法生效時已存在的法律。
The country's High Court had agreed with him. A later appeal restored much of the provisions on the basis that the constitution can shield laws already in place when it came into force in 1976.
樞密院認定,爭議條文是1986年制定的新法律的一部分,因此可以依憲法對基本權利的保障來檢視。
The Privy Council concluded that the disputed provisions formed part of a new set of laws enacted in 1986. As a result, they could be tested against the constitution's guarantees of fundamental rights.
法官也認為,條文對私人生活的干預過重,無法合理化。法官一致作出判決,也駁回該國檢察總長另行提出的交叉上訴。
The judges also found that the interference with private life was too severe to justify the provisions. The decision was unanimous, and the judges rejected a separate appeal by the country's attorney general.
至於條文應如何調整,法官將先收取進一步的書面陳述,再作出最終命令。他們初步認為應維持高等法院原先的命令。
The judges will receive further written arguments before issuing a final order on how the provisions should be modified. They said their provisional view was that the High Court's original order should stand.
